Make a Payment
Personal Insurance
American Commerce Insurance Co.
| Regular Mail | American Commerce Insurance Co. P.O. 709102 Webster, MA 01570-9102 |
| Overnight Mail | American Commerce Insurance Co. 3590 Twin Creeks Dr. Columbus, OH 43218 |
| Secure Online Payment | Click Here |
AIG Insurance Co
| Regular Mail | Premier Client Solutions PO Box 28377 New York, NY 10087-8377 |
| Overnight Mail | JPMorgan Chase – Lockbox Processing Premier Client Solutions, Box #28377 4 Chase Metrotech Center, 7th Floor East Brooklyn, NY 11245 (888) 978-5371 |
| Phone Payment | 888-573-5371 |
American Modern Insurance Co.
| Regular Mail | American Modern P.O. Box 5323 Cincinnatti, OH 45201 |
| Overnight Mail | American Modern 7000 Midland Blvd. Amelia, OH 45102 |
| Secure Online Payment: | Click Here |
Andover Insurance Co.
| Regular Mail | The Andover Companies P.O. Box 1983 Andover, MA 01810 |
| Overnight Mail | The Andover Companies 95 Old River Road Andover, MA 01810-1078 |
| Phone Payment | 800-225-0770 |
| Secure Online Payment: | Click Here |
Chubb Insurance Co.
| Regular Mail | Chubb Group of Insurance Co PO Box 7247-0180 Philadelphia, PA 19170-0180 |
| Phone Payment | 1-800-682-4822 |
| Secure Online Payment: | Click Here |
Cumberland Insurance Group
| Regular Mail | Cumberland Ins. Group 633 Shiloh Pike Bridgeton, NJ 08302 |
| Phone Payment | 800-232-6992 |
| Secure Online Payment: | Click Here |
Encompass Insurance Co.
| Regular Mail | Encompass Insurance P.O. Box 4310 Carol Stream, Illinois 30197-4310 |
| Overnight Mail | Encompass Insurance 2100 West Corporate Drive P.O. Box 4310 Addison, Illinois 60101 |
| Phone Payment | 866-430-2916 |
| Secure Online Payment: | Click Here |
FMI Insurance Company
| Regular Mail | FMI Insurance Co. 5 Broad Street Branchville, NJ 07826 |
| Phone Payment | 800-336-3642 |
| Secure Online Payment: | Click Here |
Foremost Insurance Co.
| Regular Mail | Foremost Insurance Company P.O. Box 0915 Carol Stream, IL 60132-0915 |
| Overnight Mail | Foremost Insurance c/o Citibank Lockbox Operation 8430 West Bryn Mawr Avenue, 3rd Floor Chicago, IL 60631 |
| Phone Payment | 800-527-3905 |
| Secure Online Payment: | Click Here |
MetLife Insurance Co.
| Regular Mail | MetLife Auto & Home P.O. Box 41753 Philadelphia, PA 19101 |
| Overnight Mail | RemitcoMetLife Auto & Home Lockbox 941753 2080 Cabot Blvd. West Langhorne, PA 19047 |
| Phone Payment | 800-255-0332 |
Mercer Insurance Co.
| Regular Mail | Mercer Insurance Companies P.O. Box 947 Lock Haven, PA 17745 |
| Phone Payment | 888-704-0635 |
| Secure Online Payment: | Click Here |
Mercury Insurance Co.
Auto Insurance
| Regular Mail | Mercury Insurance Group P.O. Box – 11995 Santa Ana, CA 92711 |
| Phone Payment | 800. 503.3724 |
| Secure Online Payment: | Click Here |
Mercury Insurance Co.
Homeowners Insurance
| Regular Mail | Mercury Insurance Group P.O. Box – 5600 or 5700 Rancho Cucamonga, CA 91729 |
| Phone Payment | 800. 503.3724 |
| Secure Online Payment: | Click Here |
Palisades + Plymouth Rock Insurance Co.
| Regular Mail | Palisades PO Box 856157 Louisville, KY 40285-6157 |
| Phone Payment | 888.725.9004 |
| Secure Online Payment: | Click Here |
Peerless Insurance Co.
| Regular Mail | Peerless Insurance Co. P.O. Box 703 Keene, NH 03431 |
| Phone Payment | 800-228-7830 |
| Secure Online Payment: | Click Here |
PersonalUmbrella.com
| Regular Mail | Personal Umbrella P.O. Box 88586 Emeryville, CA 94662 |
| Overnight Mail | Personal Umbrella 5835 Doyle Street, Suite 115 Emeryville, CA 94608 |
Progressive Insurance Co.
| You can pay this past due premium by regular mail by sending payment to the address provided on your invoice or by: | |
| Phone Payment | 800-776-4737 |
| Secure Online Payment: | Click Here |
Safeco Insurance Company
| Regular Mail | Safeco P.O. Box 6476 Carol Stream, IL 60197-6476 |
| Phone Payment | 888.723.3260 |
| Secure Online Payment: | Click Here |
Selective Insurance Co.
| Regular Mail | Selective Ins Co of America Box 371468 Pittsburgh, PA 15250-7468 |
| Phone Payment | 888-974-7400 |
| Secure Online Payment: | Click Here |
Selective Insurance Co.
FLOOD POLICIES ONLY
| Regular Mail | Selective Insurance-Flood Lockbox #2747 P.O. Box 8500 Philadelphia, PA 19178-2747 |
| Overnight Mail | Selective Insurance- Lockbox #2747 401 Market Street Philadelphia, PA 19106 |
Tower Insurance Co.
| Regular Mail | Tower Group Companies Box 371898 Pittsburgh, PA 15251-7898 |
| Overnight Mail | Tower Group Companies Attn: 371898 500 Ross Street 154-0470 Pittsburgh, PA 15250 |
| Phone Payment | 877-883-6599 |
| Secure Online Payment: | Click Here |
Travelers Insurance Co.
| Regular Mail | Travelers Personal InsurancePO Box 660307 Dallas, TX 75266-307 |
| Overnight Mail | Travelers Attn: PI 660307 1500 Dragon Street, Ste. A Dallas, TX 75207 |
| Phone Payment | 800.842.5075 |
| Secure Online Payment: | Click Here |
Don't See Your Provider?
Fill out the form below and someone will be in contact with you right away!
Excellent customer service. Every time.
We’ve built a company that values our customers, we empower our employees to do great work. We pride ourselves on providing each one of our customers with an outstanding experience every time they do business with us. Our people are our greatest asset and we take the hiring and training process seriously. Find out why our customers trust us to protect their assets.
Service Center
Let’s Get In Touch
Join us and get answers on how to find the right insurance, protect your assets, plan for your future, and more!
New Jersey Office
Florida Office
We shop multiple providers to find our clients the best New Jersey Homeowner’s Insurance!
©2021 Eastern Insurors, LLC. All rights reserved. Read our Privacy Policy & Terms & Conditions for more.